This was in the comments thread of the SUV Throwdown post, but I think it deserves its own post.
Cookie the Dog's Owner: "Here, I want to talk about interesting wheels with a group of friends. I think that isn't too much to ask."
I couldn't agree more with that. I think we've enjoyed that for the most part, and any straying from that standard is a failure on my part. My apologies for not being around to set the tone last week.
I'm a seasoned Usenet warrior, and from that unmoderated perspective the SUV conversation was a pretty minor skirmish. But nowadays I tend to participate on blogs that have clear guidelines, and it's nice to have a higher signal-to-noise ratio. Perhaps it's time to explicitly lay out some comment guidelines that formalize what we already have--a fun place to hang out where mutual respect (for people, not cars) rules.
That's not just because it's what I want, and what the majority of the commenters here seem to want. There's a bigger picture here. This site is run by a major multi-national corporation, and my time is being donated by that same major multi-national corporation. If this site becomes something that said multi-national corporation no longer wants to be associated with, this site could be deemed as longer worth keeping around. I'm not saying it would--frankly, I've enjoyed stunningly complete editorial freedom here--but I don't want to tempt fate.
These are based loosely on the best comment guidelines I've seen. Any comments that don't conform, judged by my own highly subjective criteria, run the risk of being edited in this way:
COMMENT: "Cletus, you are a <don't insult other commenters>."
Comment Guidelines
1. It's okay to disagree.
GOOD: "John, you're totally wrong--Toyotas aren't boring cars. You've obviously never driven my Echo--it's pure excitement in automotive form."
2. It's not okay to insult other commenters or to make things personal. Treat others with respect.
BAD: "John, you're an idiot, and I hate you. You don't know the first thing about cars, you have bad breath, and you're a Communist."
3. It's okay to insult cars.
GOOD: "My God, that Echo is godawful."
4. It's okay to insult Chris, as long as it's at least somewhat witty and not profane.
GOOD: "Chris, your automotive tastes betray your 46 IQ."
5. Try to keep the language at or below the PG-13 level.
6. No politics or religion.
I've found politics and religion to be incredibly corrosive to respectful online conversation. There are plenty of places to talk about those subjects--places that would offer a far more enriching conversation on the topic. We're not trying to solve the world's problems here.
One exception--feel free to adopt Car Lust as your personal religion or preferred political system.
7. When in doubt, use common sense and the Golden Rule.
Would you feel comfortable with your mother, father, boss, child, or prospective significant other reading your comment? Are you comfortable that if you made this comment in person that you wouldn't be punched in the face? If not, you might want to take another look at it.
As I said in the comments thread of the other post, I realize I'm trying to nurture something a little out of the ordinary here--an Internet community based on mutual respect--and so those of us used to the more caustic communication used elsewhere may need to retune a little bit. It's inevitable we'll have a few bumps in the road, but we'll get through it.
Honestly, before the big SUV thread, I can think of only one or two comments in the history of this blog that would warrant any action on my part.
I've already been accused of being a Nazi once in the last few weeks, so ...
--Chris H.
Guy Montag wrote:
It's a totally fair question, and one I want to respond to. This blog doesn't have a lot going for it--certainly not newsworthiness or expertise--but one thing it does have is lots and lots of baseless and wildly formed opinion. Impugn that, and you impugn the only arguably worthwhile part of this blog!