Birth Year Fantasy Garage--Introduction
Birth Year Fantasy Garage--Cookie the Dog's Owner (1961)
Birth Year Fantasy Garage--Tigerstrypes (1989)
Birth Year Fantasy Garage--Anthony Cagle (1962)
Birth Year Fantasy Garage--Chris Hafner (1976)
At first glance, it might seem foolish and misguided to assemble a $100K Fantasy Garage exclusively from cars available in my birth year of 1976. Compared to the classic 1950s and high-horsepower 1960s, the 1970s seem to be remembered by enthusiasts as the decade in which car enthusiasm cratered.
The first fuel crisis and emissions standards had sapped horsepower and drivability, leaving the fire-breathing muscle cars of the 1960s largely extinct by the early 1970s. Imports were still rare and out of the mainstream, the domestics were experimenting half-heartedly with downsizing, and the disco era manifested in the size and styling excess of the personal luxury land yachts.
This is a pretty dire picture, but I'd argue that there were still good cars made in 1976, and even those cars that weren't empirically good are at least interesting for a car enthusiast in 2015 who doesn't need to depend on them for daily transportation. In fact, the relative unpopularity of mid-to-late 1970s cars makes them much less expensive and more accessible than the more universally loved cars out there. Interesting and inexpensive? Sounds like a perfect formula for Car Lust.
I outlined the rules in the introduction, but I included a few personal rules. For example, I excluded any cars that I have already owned--which explains the absence of the Jeep Wagoneer, Cadillac Eldorado, Ford Gran Torino Wagon and Plymouth Valiant from my list. I also organized my choices into specific roles to curb my natural inclination to invest solely in land yachts and sports coupes. I chose average values from Hagerty and NADA in cases where actual listings weren't available; Hagerty's average value corresponds to something between Condition 2 (drivable show car) and Condition 3 (very nice driver), which perfectly fits my expectations for these cars. The eBay listings I chose were finished, above-reserve listings, in which the car actually sold.
In many cases I was faced with tough choices in a given category, but in the case of a tie I tried to break that tie in favor of the car more evocative of its time and most likely to put me in a 1976 mindset. Below I'm starting with my chosen daily driver and then working from most expensive choice to least.